lilmgenius/paperthin

whychk

Right after you pick an option, have a fresh outsider find the sharpest gap in the choice, then explain that gap in your own words, one gap at a time.

Quelltext ansehen

Verwendung

  1. Installationsbefehl kopieren und das Quellpaket vor der Installation in der eigenen Agentenumgebung prüfen.
  2. Benötigte Werkzeuge, Zugangsdaten und Hosts im Original prüfen.
  3. Eingabe und gewünschtes Ergebnis beschreiben und die Ausgabe mit den Quellen abgleichen.
npx skills add https://github.com/lilmgenius/paperthin --skill whychk

Vor dem Start

  • Die Installation umfasst weder Modellabo noch API-Kontingent oder Dateizugriffsrechte.
  • Sterne und Installationen zeigen Aktivität, keine unabhängige Qualitäts- oder Sicherheitsprüfung.
Originales Skill-Dokument

Aus dem Quell-Repository gerendert; Überschriften, Beispiele, Code, Tabellen, Links und Bilder bleiben erhalten.

Make the person who chose explain why, one gap at a time, before the decision counts as earned.

Goal

A decision made after options were laid out without arguments can feel settled while resting on assumptions nobody said aloud. This check surfaces them one by one and lets the user close each with their own reasoning. It runs only when the user reaches for it, because a reflex that challenges every decision would breed chronic self-doubt.

Workflow

  1. Run when the user invokes this skill right after a decision, typically one picked from options presented without arguments; it never starts on its own. Restate the decision neutrally in one or two sentences, with no reasoning attached, and do not let the user borrow reasoning that was never given.
  2. Launch a fresh, context-free sub-session that never watched the decision being made. Give it only the restated decision, never the options discussion, your reasoning, or the session history. Never use the session that made the choice as the critic; if the host cannot start a separate session, say so and stop rather than critique the choice yourself.
  3. Ask the critic what a skeptical outsider would question, what is assumed but unstated, and what must be true for the choice to hold. Its answers are candidate gaps; rank them by how much of the decision falls if each one is wrong.
  4. Take the sharpest unresolved gap from its answer and put exactly that one gap to the user, asking them to explain it in their own words. Never hand over a checklist.
  5. Judge the answer. The gap closes only when the explanation resolves the actual question. If it restates the question, deflects, or leans on authority ("the agent suggested it"), it stays open.
  6. After a shallow answer, narrow to the exact part that stayed vague and ask about that. Never repeat the same question and never widen back to a generic "are you sure?".
  7. Continue with the next sharpest gap. Stop when every gap is explained, or when narrowing on one gap yields nothing new and the user leaves it open. Both endings are valid.
  8. For an unexplained gap, name its specific assumption and flag the decision for re-review, written where the decision is recorded (its plan, issue or commit message) so the flag outlives the conversation. The flag means the decision is not yet earned, not that it was wrong. Never force a resolution and never let the user paper over the gap.

Rules

  • The critic is always a separate, context-free sub-session that receives the decision alone.
  • Exactly one gap per turn, the sharpest unresolved one.
  • Every reason that closes a gap comes from the user. This skill supplies none, not even as a hint or a leading question.
  • Reject answers that restate the question, deflect, or cite authority; say why in one line.
  • An open gap carries forward as a flag and is never dropped or softened.
  • Stay neutral about whether the decision is right; the check measures understanding, not outcome.

Verification

Before finishing:

  1. The signal is the change between the user's first answer and the answer after narrowing, not the absence of objections.
  2. Every closed gap traces to an explanation from the user that resolved the actual question.
  3. Every open gap is listed with its specific assumption and carries forward as a flag for re-review.
  4. No reason that closed a gap came from this skill.
aus demselben Repository

Weitere Skills

Alle Skills
lilmgenius
Community

re0-order

Move items only, reword nothing; realign a listing whose order has gone arbitrary (a list, table, catalog, sections, an enum) into a logical sequence under one stated principle. Nothing is added or removed. Use when the user names a listing, or a scope holding one, whose order no longer helps a reader follow the set, or when a pipeline the user invoked passes that scope on. Acts only inside that scope.

Installationen / 1h
5
GitHub Stars
1463
Aktualisiert
15. Nov.
lilmgenius
Community

readback

Verify the model's understanding of a user's instruction before spending non-trivial work. Use when a request is long, bundled, high-stakes, hard to undo, or has ambiguous scope or referents such as this, that, it, the other one, whatever is cleaner, or whichever order makes sense. Restate internally, cross-check against available context, proceed silently when resolved, and surface only a genuine surviving fork.

Installationen / 1h
5
GitHub Stars
1463
Aktualisiert
15. Nov.
lilmgenius
Community

aim

When data lands with a thin ask (files, a repo, a paste, a chat scrollback), read it and propose what the user is trying to do with it for them to confirm. Use the moment material arrives without a fully-formed ask, or when the ask reads thinner than the data suggests.

Installationen / 1h
4
GitHub Stars
1463
Aktualisiert
15. Nov.
lilmgenius
Community

autobahn

Carve guardrail-adjacent items out of scope with safe alternatives before risk-adjacent work starts, then run the safe remainder at full strength in a fresh subagent that only ever sees the carved prompt, never the risky input. Use when a task includes stealth, scraping, privacy, IP, policy, licensing, security, or other safety-adjacent material that could be silently dropped, over-elaborated, or needlessly diluted. Fires on the impulse, not only the topic: the moment you notice yourself about t

Installationen / 1h
4
GitHub Stars
1463
Aktualisiert
15. Nov.