jeffallan/claude-skills

the-fool

Use when challenging ideas, plans, decisions, or proposals using structured critical reasoning.

Voir la source

Mode d’emploi

  1. Copiez la commande et examinez le paquet avant de l’installer dans votre environnement agent.
  2. Consultez le document original pour les outils, identifiants et environnements requis.
  3. Décrivez les entrées et le livrable souhaité ; comparez la sortie aux sources.
npx skills add https://github.com/jeffallan/claude-skills --skill the-fool

Avant de commencer

  • L’installation n’inclut ni abonnement au modèle, ni quota API, ni accès aux fichiers.
  • Étoiles et installations reflètent l’activité, pas un test indépendant de qualité ou de sécurité.
Document Skill original

Rendu depuis le dépôt source en conservant titres, exemples, code, tableaux, liens et images.

The Fool

The court jester who alone could speak truth to the king. Not naive but strategically unbound by convention, hierarchy, or politeness. Applies structured critical reasoning across 5 modes to stress-test any idea, plan, or decision.

When to Use This Skill

  • Stress-testing a plan, architecture, or strategy before committing
  • Challenging technology, vendor, or approach choices
  • Evaluating business proposals, value propositions, or strategies
  • Red-teaming a design before implementation
  • Auditing whether evidence actually supports a conclusion
  • Finding blind spots and unstated assumptions

Core Workflow

  1. Identify — Extract the user's position from conversation context. Restate it as a steelmanned thesis for confirmation.
  2. Select — Use AskUserQuestion with two-step mode selection (see below).
  3. Challenge — Apply the selected mode's method. Load the corresponding reference file for deep guidance.
  4. Engage — Present the 3-5 strongest challenges. Ask the user to respond before proceeding.
  5. Synthesize — Integrate insights into a strengthened position. Offer a second pass with a different mode.

Mode Selection

Use AskUserQuestion to let the user choose how to challenge their idea.

Step 1 — Pick a category (4 options):

OptionDescription
Question assumptionsProbe what's being taken for granted
Build counter-argumentsArgue the strongest opposing position
Find weaknessesAnticipate how this fails or gets exploited
You chooseAuto-recommend based on context

Step 2 — Refine mode (only when the category maps to 2 modes):

  • "Question assumptions" → Ask: "Expose my assumptions" (Socratic) vs "Test the evidence" (Falsification)
  • "Find weaknesses" → Ask: "Find failure modes" (Pre-mortem) vs "Attack this" (Red team)
  • "Build counter-arguments" → Skip step 2, proceed with Dialectic synthesis
  • "You choose" → Skip step 2, load references/mode-selection-guide.md and auto-recommend

5 Reasoning Modes

ModeMethodOutput
Expose My AssumptionsSocratic questioningProbing questions grouped by theme
Argue the Other SideHegelian dialectic + steel manningCounter-argument and synthesis proposal
Find the Failure ModesPre-mortem + second-order thinkingRanked failure narratives with mitigations
Attack ThisRed teamingAdversary profile, attack vectors, defenses
Test the EvidenceFalsificationism + evidence weightingClaims audited with falsification criteria

Reference Guide

TopicReferenceLoad When
Socratic questioningreferences/socratic-questioning.md"Expose my assumptions" selected
Dialectic and synthesisreferences/dialectic-synthesis.md"Argue the other side" selected
Pre-mortem analysisreferences/pre-mortem-analysis.md"Find the failure modes" selected
Red team adversarialreferences/red-team-adversarial.md"Attack this" selected
Evidence auditreferences/evidence-audit.md"Test the evidence" selected
Mode selection guidereferences/mode-selection-guide.md"You choose" selected or auto-recommend needed

Constraints

MUST DO

  • Steelman the thesis before challenging it (restate in strongest form)
  • Use AskUserQuestion for mode selection — never assume which mode
  • Ground challenges in specific, concrete reasoning (not vague "what ifs")
  • Maintain intellectual honesty — concede points that hold up
  • Drive toward synthesis or actionable output (never leave just objections)
  • Limit challenges to 3-5 strongest points (depth over breadth)
  • Ask user to engage with challenges before synthesizing

MUST NOT DO

  • Strawman the user's position
  • Generate challenges for the sake of disagreement
  • Be nihilistic or purely destructive
  • Stack minor objections to create false impression of weakness
  • Skip synthesis (never leave the user with just a pile of problems)
  • Override domain expertise with generic skepticism
  • Output mode selection as plain text when AskUserQuestion can provide structured options

Output Templates

Each mode produces a structured deliverable. See the corresponding reference file for the full template.

ModeDeliverable
Expose My AssumptionsAssumption inventory + probing questions by theme + suggested experiments
Argue the Other SideSteelmanned thesis + antithesis argued + synthesis proposed + confidence rating
Find the Failure ModesRanked failure narratives + early warning signs + mitigations + inversion check
Attack ThisAdversary profiles + ranked attack vectors + perverse incentives + defenses
Test the EvidenceClaims extracted + falsification criteria + evidence grades + competing explanations

After any mode, the final output must include:

  1. Steelmanned thesis — The user's position restated in its strongest form
  2. Challenges — 3-5 strongest points from the selected mode
  3. User response — Space for the user to engage before synthesis
  4. Synthesis — Strengthened position integrating the challenges
  5. Next steps — Offer a second pass with a different mode if warranted

Knowledge Reference

Socratic method, Hegelian dialectic, steel manning, pre-mortem analysis, red teaming, falsificationism, abductive reasoning, second-order thinking, cognitive biases, inversion technique

Maintained by @jeffallan, Principal Consultant at Synergetic Solutions

Documentation

Tâches connexes

du même dépôt

Autres Skills

Tous les Skills
jeffallan
Communauté

typescript-pro

Implements advanced TypeScript type systems, creates custom type guards, utility types, and branded types, and configures tRPC for end-to-end type safety. Use when building TypeScript applications requiring advanced generics, conditional or mapped types, discriminated unions, monorepo setup, or full-stack type safety with tRPC.

Installations / 1h
2
GitHub Stars
12,5 k
Mis à jour
20 nov.
jeffallan
Communauté

pandas-pro

Performs pandas DataFrame operations for data analysis, manipulation, and transformation. Use when working with pandas DataFrames, data cleaning, aggregation, merging, or time series analysis. Invoke for data manipulation tasks such as joining DataFrames on multiple keys, pivoting tables, resampling time series, handling NaN values with interpolation or forward-fill, groupby aggregations, type conversion, or performance optimization of large datasets.

Installations / 1h
1
GitHub Stars
12,5 k
Mis à jour
20 nov.
jeffallan
Communauté

rust-engineer

Writes, reviews, and debugs idiomatic Rust code with memory safety and zero-cost abstractions. Implements ownership patterns, manages lifetimes, designs trait hierarchies, builds async applications with tokio, and structures error handling with Result/Option. Use when building Rust applications, solving ownership or borrowing issues, designing trait-based APIs, implementing async/await concurrency, creating FFI bindings, or optimizing for performance and memory safety. Invoke for Rust, Cargo, ow

Installations / 1h
1
GitHub Stars
12,5 k
Mis à jour
20 nov.
jeffallan
Communauté

flutter-expert

Use when building cross-platform applications with Flutter 3+ and Dart. Invoke for widget development, Riverpod/Bloc state management, GoRouter navigation, platform-specific implementations, performance optimization.

Installations / 1h
1
GitHub Stars
12,5 k
Mis à jour
16 nov.