poteto/noodle

adversarial-review

Adversarial code review using cross-model approach.

소스 보기

사용 방법

  1. 설치 명령을 복사하고 자신의 에이전트 환경에 설치하기 전에 소스 패키지를 확인하세요.
  2. 필요한 도구, 인증 정보, 지원 환경은 원본 문서에서 확인하세요.
  3. 입력과 원하는 산출물을 설명하고 출처와 결과를 대조하세요.
npx skills add https://github.com/poteto/noodle --skill adversarial-review

시작 전 확인

  • 설치에는 모델 구독, API 한도, 파일 접근 권한이 포함되지 않습니다.
  • 별점 수와 설치 수는 활동 지표이며 독립적인 품질·보안 검증이 아닙니다.
원본 Skill 문서

원본 저장소의 제목, 예시, 코드, 표, 링크, 이미지를 유지해 표시합니다.

Adversarial Review

Spawn reviewers on the opposite model to challenge work. Reviewers attack from distinct lenses grounded in brain principles. The deliverable is a synthesized verdict — do NOT make changes.

Hard constraint: Reviewers MUST run via the opposite model's CLI (codex exec or claude -p). Do NOT use subagents, the Agent tool, or any internal delegation mechanism as reviewers — those run on your own model, which defeats the purpose.

Step 1 — Load Principles

Read brain/principles.md. Follow every [[wikilink]] and read each linked principle file. These govern reviewer judgments.

Step 2 — Determine Scope and Intent

Identify what to review from context (recent diffs, referenced plans, user message).

Determine the intent — what the author is trying to achieve. This is critical: reviewers challenge whether the work achieves the intent well, not whether the intent is correct. State the intent explicitly before proceeding.

Assess change size:

SizeThresholdReviewers
Small< 50 lines, 1-2 files1 (Skeptic)
Medium50-200 lines, 3-5 files2 (Skeptic + Architect)
Large200+ lines or 5+ files3 (Skeptic + Architect + Minimalist)

Read references/reviewer-lenses.md for lens definitions.

Step 3 — Detect Model and Spawn Reviewers

Create a temp directory for reviewer output:

sh
REVIEW_DIR=$(mktemp -d /tmp/adversarial-review.XXXXXX)

Determine which model you are, then spawn reviewers on the opposite:

If you are Claude — spawn Codex reviewers via codex exec:

sh
codex exec --skip-git-repo-check -o "$REVIEW_DIR/skeptic.md" "prompt" 2>/dev/null

Use --profile edit only if the reviewer needs to run tests. Default to read-only. Run with run_in_background: true, monitor via TaskOutput with block: true, timeout: 600000.

If you are Codex — spawn Claude reviewers via claude CLI:

sh
claude -p "prompt" > "$REVIEW_DIR/skeptic.md" 2>/dev/null

Run with run_in_background: true.

Name each output file after the lens: skeptic.md, architect.md, minimalist.md.

Build each reviewer's prompt using the template in references/reviewer-prompt.md.

Step 4 — Verify and Synthesize Verdict

Before reading reviewer output, log which CLI was used and confirm the output files exist:

sh
echo "reviewer_cli=codex|claude"
ls "$REVIEW_DIR"/*.md

If any output file is missing or empty, note the failure in the verdict — do not silently skip a reviewer.

Read each reviewer's output file from $REVIEW_DIR/. Deduplicate overlapping findings. Produce a single verdict using the format in references/verdict-format.md.

Step 5 — Render Judgment

After synthesizing the reviewers, apply your own judgment. Using the stated intent and brain principles as your frame, state which findings you would accept and which you would reject — and why. Reviewers are adversarial by design; not every finding warrants action. Call out false positives, overreach, and findings that mistake style for substance.

Append the Lead Judgment section to the verdict (see references/verdict-format.md).

같은 저장소의 Skills

더 많은 Skills

모든 Skills