smartworldarafath/rea_skill

competitive-platform-analysis

Use when scoping a competitive landscape — identifying, categorising, and score-filtering a competitor set before any benchmarking begins.

소스 보기

사용 방법

  1. 설치 명령을 복사하고 자신의 에이전트 환경에 설치하기 전에 소스 패키지를 확인하세요.
  2. 필요한 도구, 인증 정보, 지원 환경은 원본 문서에서 확인하세요.
  3. 입력과 원하는 산출물을 설명하고 출처와 결과를 대조하세요.
npx skills add https://github.com/smartworldarafath/rea_skill --skill competitive-platform-analysis

시작 전 확인

  • 설치에는 모델 구독, API 한도, 파일 접근 권한이 포함되지 않습니다.
  • 별점 수와 설치 수는 활동 지표이며 독립적인 품질·보안 검증이 아닙니다.
원본 Skill 문서

원본 저장소의 제목, 예시, 코드, 표, 링크, 이미지를 유지해 표시합니다.

Competitive Platform Analysis

Use this skill to decide who to benchmark and where to find them before any scoring begins. A competitive analysis is only as good as its frame: the wrong set makes the client look either unbeatable or doomed. The goal is a defensible, decision-relevant set — not an exhaustive census.

When to Activate

  • About to start a competitive benchmarking project and need to define the competitor set first.
  • Unsure which companies belong in Direct / Adjacent / Aspirational tiers.
  • Need a defensible, pruned scope for a market landscape report.
  • Has a positioning brief and wants to identify who contests that position.
  • First step before running benchmark-methodology.

Client positioning brief (establish first)

Before scoping the set, establish the client's positioning brief. If you don't already have it, run a short brand-discovery interview to elicit it — do not invent one and do not scope the set blind. The brief supplies:

  • Identity / aesthetic register — what kind of studio or company this is and

how it presents itself.

  • Offer — what services or products it delivers.
  • Target clients — who it sells to.
  • Differentiator — the moat or positioning argument the client believes in.
  • Scoping consequence — the implication for how to weight competitors (e.g.,

prioritize by distinctiveness vs. capability overlap vs. price).

  • Strategic tension — the paired axes that define the client's white-space

(e.g., memorability × hireability).

Do not proceed without the positioning brief. A competitor list scoped without the client's lens is noise, not intelligence. The scoping consequence in particular determines which competitors are strong rivals (those that contest the client's moat) vs. merely overlapping on service menu.

Selection criteria

For each candidate, capture these axes — they decide both inclusion and tier:

  • Size / model — solo, micro-studio (2–8), boutique (sub-30), mid-size

agency. Match the client's own band; same-band studios are the realistic head-to-head set.

  • Niche / specialization — how closely the candidate's focus overlaps with

the client's offer. Tighter overlap = more direct.

  • Geography / market — EU vs US vs global-remote; language; time-zone reach.

Note whether they win the same clients the client targets.

  • Pricing & engagement model — productized sprints, retainer, project,

day-rate; transparent vs "contact us". Signals positioning maturity.

  • Portfolio style — generic vs. opinionated/editorial vs. contrarian. Closer

to the client's aesthetic register = more they contest the client's distinctiveness.

  • Technical depth / craft maturity — relevant if the client's credibility

story includes public process work, open tooling, or documented systems.

  • Brand strength — does the studio have an ownable verbal/visual identity, or

is it interchangeable? Weight this per the client's scoping consequence.

Player taxonomy — axes to populate across

Don't sort competitors into niche-specific buckets; sort them along a few generic axes so the landscape isn't skewed toward one archetype. These axes apply to any creative-service market (design, motion, copywriting, branding, content, film, etc.). Aim for breadth across each axis first, then prune to the most instructive.

  1. Positioning stance — brand-led / editorial (competes on identity,

voice, POV) vs capability-led (competes on craft, throughput, outcomes). Populate both poles; the client's closest mirror sits at its own end.

  1. Specialization — specialist (one tight discipline or vertical) vs

generalist (broad service menu). Tighter overlap with the client's focus = more direct.

  1. Size / model — solo / micro vs boutique vs mid-size vs

enterprise-scale. Same-band players are the realistic head-to-head; larger bands are the aspirational/commercial-maturity reference.

  1. Engagement format — productized (named sprints, audits, fixed packages)

vs bespoke (custom project / retainer). Signals positioning maturity.

  1. Distinctiveness posture — conventional / safe vs *contrarian /

manifesto-driven*. The opinionated end is key for distinctiveness benchmarking in any niche.

  1. Evidence / credibility model — outcome-led (metrics, named clients,

case depth) vs aesthetic-led (portfolio, awards). Tells you how each player earns trust.

  1. Brand strength of the operator — interchangeable vs *cult / ownable

identity* (including senior independents who prove the "memorable solo brand" model).

  1. Market / reach — local / regional vs global-remote; note whether they

win the same clients the client targets.

Plot each candidate on the relevant axes; a competitor is direct when it sits near the client on positioning, specialization, size, and market at once.

Competitive tiers (how the set resolves)

Group the final set into three tiers — this structure carries through to the report:

  • Direct — same band, overlapping offer, same client targets. The realistic

head-to-head.

  • Adjacent — partial overlap (one capability, or a different client size)

that pressures at the edges.

  • Aspirational — players the client is not competing with today but whose

brand or commercial maturity sets the bar to aim at.

  • *(Watch also for substitutes: no-code/AI tools, in-house teams, generalist

freelancers — note as a threat vector, not a profiled competitor unless materially relevant.)*

Data sources (where to look)

Match the source to the dimension you need. The platform types below are generic; substitute the ones native to the client's niche (e.g. Dribbble/Behance for design, showreel/Vimeo for motion, writing samples/published work for copy):

  • Portfolio / craft platforms — craft quality, range, aesthetic register

(e.g. Dribbble, Behance, Vimeo, or the niche's equivalent showcase).

  • Awards / curated showcases — craft ambition and editorial recognition;

over-indexes on flashy, so cross-check commercial credibility (e.g. Awwwards, industry award lists).

  • Competitor's own site — primary source for positioning, voice, offer

packaging, pricing posture, named clients, manifesto/POV.

  • LinkedIn — team size/model, founder narrative, post cadence, client logos,

geography.

  • Review directories — reviews, named clients, project sizes, engagement

models; strongest signal for commercial credibility and enterprise-readiness (e.g. Clutch.co or the niche's equivalent).

  • Open / public work — process repos, published samples, open creative

output: depth and craft-transparency evidence.

  • Conference talks / podcasts / newsletters — thought-leadership depth and

POV ownership.

Always verify claims across at least two sources before treating a competitor attribute as fact (self-reported site copy ≠ verified outcome). Carry an adversarial-verification discipline into every profile.

Scoring matrix template (selection stage)

A lightweight pre-filter to decide who graduates into full benchmarking. Score 1–5; keep candidates that score high on either distinctiveness or credibility — the client's strategic tension means both poles are instructive.

CandidatePositioning stanceSpecializationSize bandTierOffer overlap (1–5)Distinctiveness (1–5)Commercial credibility (1–5)Craft proximity (1–5)Include?

Rules of thumb (apply per the client's scoping consequence in the positioning brief):

  • High distinctiveness and high credibility → must-profile (proves the

client's target tension is achievable).

  • High distinctiveness, low credibility → cautionary case (memorable but

un-hireable — a potential failure mode to learn from).

  • High credibility, low distinctiveness → "competent but forgettable" mass the

client defines itself against.

  • Low on both → drop unless needed for landscape breadth.

Output of this stage

A scoped, tiered competitor set (typically 10–18 candidates → 8–12 profiled), each tagged with its axis positions, tier, and source links, ready to hand to benchmark-methodology.

Anti-Patterns

  • Scoping without a positioning brief. A competitor list built without the client's lens is noise. The brief determines what counts as a real rival.
  • Listing every similar company. The goal is a defensible 10–18 candidate set, not a census. Breadth without pruning makes benchmarking unmanageable.
  • Blurring the Direct/Adjacent/Aspirational tiers. These tiers serve different strategic purposes. Mixing them produces a flat list that can't drive decisions.
  • Relying on a single source per competitor. Self-reported site copy is marketing, not fact. Verify attributes across at least two sources.
  • Jumping straight to scoring. This skill scopes and tiers the set. Benchmark-methodology handles scoring. Don't conflate the two steps.

Examples

Scenario: A boutique brand-identity studio (2-person, EU-remote, productized sprints, contrarian/manifesto-driven aesthetic) wants to scope its competitive set before benchmarking. The strategic tension from the positioning brief is memorability × hireability.

Step 1 — eight-axis population (sample candidates):

CandidatePositioning stanceSpecializationSize bandEngagementDistinctivenessEvidence modelBrand strengthMarket
Studio Abrand-led / editorialidentity onlymicroproductizedcontrarianaesthetic-ledcultglobal-remote
Studio Bcapability-ledbroad DS+motionboutiquebespokeconventionaloutcome-ledinterchangeableUS
Agency Ccapability-ledbrand+digitalmid-sizeretainerconventionaloutcome-ledinterchangeableEU
Freelancer Dbrand-ledbrand voice onlysoloday-rateeditorialaesthetic-ledownableglobal
Studio Ebrand-ledbrand strategymicroproductizedmanifesto-drivenoutcome-ledcultEU-remote

Step 2 — pre-filter scoring (client scoping consequence: weight distinctiveness because the client's moat is POV-first, not capability breadth):

CandidateOffer overlap (1–5)Distinctiveness (1–5)Commercial credibility (1–5)Craft proximity (1–5)TierInclude?
Studio A5535Direct✓ must-profile
Studio B3253Adjacent✓ credibility anchor
Agency C2152Aspirational✓ scale reference
Freelancer D4424Direct✓ cautionary case
Studio E5544Direct✓ must-profile

Step 3 — output handed to `benchmark-methodology`: Five candidates (3 Direct, 1 Adjacent, 1 Aspirational), each tagged with axis positions, tier, and source links. Studio A and Studio E are the sharpest head-to-head rivals; Freelancer D is the "memorable but un-hireable" cautionary case to learn from.

Related Skills

  • brand-discovery — use first to establish the positioning brief and strategic tension that scopes the competitor set.
  • benchmark-methodology — the next step; takes the tiered set and scores each competitor across nine dimensions.
같은 저장소의 Skills

더 많은 Skills

모든 Skills
smartworldarafath
커뮤니티

agent-introspection-debugging

Structured self-debugging workflow for AI agent failures using capture, diagnosis, contained recovery, and introspection reports. Use when an agent run fails and you need a reproducible diagnosis instead of a retry.

1시간 설치 수
2
GitHub Stars
5
업데이트
11월 8일
smartworldarafath
커뮤니티

agent-reach

Read-only access to internet platforms (Twitter/X, Reddit, YouTube subtitles, GitHub, LinkedIn, Bilibili, web). Use when the agent needs to search, read web links, retrieve social discussions, CVE/vulnerability intel, or when standard web search/fetch is blocked or insufficient.

1시간 설치 수
2
GitHub Stars
5
업데이트
11월 8일
smartworldarafath
커뮤니티

agent-sort

Build an evidence-backed ECC install plan for a specific repo by sorting skills, commands, rules, hooks, and extras into DAILY vs LIBRARY buckets using parallel repo-aware review passes. Use when ECC should be trimmed to what a project actually needs instead of loading the full bundle.

1시간 설치 수
2
GitHub Stars
5
업데이트
11월 8일
smartworldarafath
커뮤니티

anti-ai-slop-writing

Produces human-sounding text that avoids detectable AI writing patterns. Activates on any writing task — tweets, emails, articles, bios, captions, reports, copy, messages, LinkedIn posts, cover letters, README files, or any content where the output must not read as AI-generated. Enforces banned vocabulary, structural variety, punctuation discipline, accuracy rules, and voice calibration. Use when the user says "write," "draft," "rewrite," "make this sound human," "anti-slop," "not AI," or any va

1시간 설치 수
2
GitHub Stars
5
업데이트
11월 8일