learnprompt/andrej-karpathy-skills

karpathy-llm-simulator

Use LLM as a simulator of expert debates and opposing viewpoints instead of getting a single sycophantic answer.

Quelltext ansehen

Verwendung

  1. Installationsbefehl kopieren und das Quellpaket vor der Installation in der eigenen Agentenumgebung prüfen.
  2. Benötigte Werkzeuge, Zugangsdaten und Hosts im Original prüfen.
  3. Eingabe und gewünschtes Ergebnis beschreiben und die Ausgabe mit den Quellen abgleichen.
npx skills add https://github.com/learnprompt/andrej-karpathy-skills --skill karpathy-llm-simulator

Vor dem Start

  • Die Installation umfasst weder Modellabo noch API-Kontingent oder Dateizugriffsrechte.
  • Sterne und Installationen zeigen Aktivität, keine unabhängige Qualitäts- oder Sicherheitsprüfung.
Originales Skill-Dokument

Aus dem Quell-Repository gerendert; Überschriften, Beispiele, Code, Tabellen, Links und Bilder bleiben erhalten.

Skill 3: LLM as Simulator(LLM模拟器思维)

Source: https://x.com/karpathy/status/2037921699824607591 | https://x.com/karpathy/status/2049907410303865030 "Drafted a blog post → LLM argue the opposite" — 31k likes

Core Principle

Don't ask what the LLM thinks. Ask it to simulate what a diverse group of experts would argue.

LLMs are trained to please. A direct question gets a sycophantic answer. A simulation request gets a distribution of real perspectives — including the uncomfortable ones.

Karpathy's method: write a draft → ask LLM to argue the strongest possible opposite position → synthesize a better view.

The 4 Simulator Modes

Mode 1: Expert Debate Panel

Best for: technical decisions, architecture choices, research directions

Simulate a structured debate between these 3 expert personas on [TOPIC/DECISION]:

Expert A: [most optimistic / pro position]
Expert B: [most skeptical / con position]  
Expert C: [pragmatic outsider / unexpected angle]

For each expert:
- State their core argument in 3 sentences
- Cite 2 specific examples or data points they'd use
- Identify what they'd say is the FATAL FLAW in the opposing view

After the debate, synthesize: what's the strongest hybrid position that survives all three critiques?

Topic: [YOUR_TOPIC]
My current position: [YOUR_DRAFT_VIEW]

Mode 2: Steel Man the Opposite

Best for: before publishing, before committing to a decision

I'm about to [ACTION / PUBLISH / DECIDE]:

[YOUR PLAN OR DRAFT]

Steel man the strongest possible argument AGAINST this. Be merciless.
Don't hedge. Don't say "while this has merit...". 
Argue as if you genuinely believe the opposite and need to convince a skeptical expert.

Then: what would it take to make my original position survive this attack?

Mode 3: Pre-Mortem Simulation

Best for: project planning, product launches, major decisions

Imagine it's [DATE 6 MONTHS FROM NOW] and [YOUR PROJECT/PLAN] has failed completely.

Simulate 3 different failure modes — each from a different root cause:
1. Technical failure: what went wrong in the implementation?
2. Strategic failure: what assumption proved wrong?
3. Execution failure: what human/process error occurred?

For each: describe the specific sequence of events that led to failure.

Then: what early warning signals would have been visible by [DATE 1 MONTH FROM NOW]?

Mode 4: Socratic Drill

Best for: testing your own understanding of a concept

I believe I understand [CONCEPT]. 

Ask me 5 increasingly hard Socratic questions to test my understanding.
After each answer I give, probe a potential gap or inconsistency.
At the end, grade my understanding on a scale of 1-10 and identify my biggest blind spot.

Start with question 1.

Anti-Sycophancy Patterns

Always add one of these to prevent the LLM from capitulating to your framing:

  • "Do not soften your critique because you think I want to hear it."
  • "If my position is clearly wrong, say so directly."
  • "Ignore that I wrote the original draft — evaluate it as an anonymous submission."
  • "Your job is to find the fatal flaw, not to validate."

Decision Framework

Before any major decision:
1. Write down your current position (1-2 paragraphs)
2. Run Mode 2 (Steel Man the Opposite)
3. Update your position based on the strongest critique
4. Run Mode 1 (Expert Debate) to get broader perspective
5. Make the decision — now you've genuinely stress-tested it

Total time: 15-20 minutes. Quality of decision: dramatically better.

When NOT to Use This

  • For factual lookups (just ask directly)
  • For code generation (use agentic engineering instead)
  • When you've already decided and need to execute (move forward, don't ruminate)

Workflow

属于工作流:反偏见决策(任何重要判断)

位置上游下游
入口用户面临重要决策时直接触发karpathy-understanding-first(验证自己是否真正理解)

完整链路:llm-simulator → understanding-first → system-prompt-learning

也在月度体检工作流中用于 stress-test 月度结论。

Prompt Contract

text
Simulate a structured debate between 3-5 expert personas with conflicting incentives on <DECISION/TOPIC>. Each persona must: state their core argument, cite specific evidence, identify the fatal flaw in opposing views. After the debate, synthesize the strongest hybrid position that survives all critiques. End with: key assumptions I must verify myself.

Verification Checklist

  • [ ] 至少有 3 个角色,且利益/立场互相冲突
  • [ ] 每个角色都给出了具体论据(不是泛泛而谈)
  • [ ] 每个角色都指出了对方的致命缺陷
  • [ ] 综合结论经受住了所有角色的攻击
  • [ ] 列出了「我必须亲自验证」的假设清单
  • [ ] 没有出现讨好用户原始立场的倾向
aus demselben Repository

Weitere Skills

Alle Skills
learnprompt
Community

karpathy-agentic-engineering

Apply Karpathy-style agentic engineering to any coding or building task. Use this skill when the user wants to set up an agent-driven workflow, needs to write a CLAUDE.md or AGENTS.md, wants to orchestrate agents with clear success criteria, or says things like "agent loop", "let the agent handle it", "agentic coding", "set up agent workflow". Includes the 7-step inner loop from Karpathy claude coding notes.

Installationen / 1h
1
GitHub Stars
130
Aktualisiert
10. Juli
learnprompt
Community

karpathy-education-first

Apply the education-first mindset — make everything you build teachable, create nano-project explanations, write for beginners. Use this skill when the user wants to explain a project to beginners, create a tutorial from code, write documentation that teaches (not just documents), make a concept accessible, or says "make this teachable", "explain like im a beginner", "nano project version", "teaching version", "explain from scratch", "blog post about this". Based on Karpathy 243-line GPT and Eur

Installationen / 1h
1
GitHub Stars
130
Aktualisiert
10. Juli
learnprompt
Community

karpathy-idea-files

Create and share ideas as abstract Gist-style specs instead of code — letting agents or others implement. Use this skill when the user wants to capture a new idea quickly, needs to write a project spec for an agent to implement, wants to share a concept without building it first, or says "write up this idea", "create a spec", "gist this", "idea file", "agent can implement this", "brief for this project". Based on Karpathy 27k-like LLM Wiki Gist post and GitHub repo.

Installationen / 1h
1
GitHub Stars
130
Aktualisiert
10. Juli
learnprompt
Community

karpathy-methodology

Apply Andrej Karpathy AI methodology and principles from his 2023-2026 insights. Use this skill when the user wants to apply Karpathy-style thinking, needs guidance on agentic engineering, LLM knowledge bases, minimalist coding, understanding-first principles, or any of the 14 core methodologies distilled from his work. Also triggers on: "karpathy method", "karpathy approach", "karpathy way", "AK style", "like karpathy does", "karpathy principles", or when user asks how Karpathy would approach a

Installationen / 1h
1
GitHub Stars
130
Aktualisiert
10. Juli