learnprompt/andrej-karpathy-skills

karpathy-llm-simulator

Use LLM as a simulator of expert debates and opposing viewpoints instead of getting a single sycophantic answer.

Vedi sorgente

Come usare

  1. Copia il comando e controlla il pacchetto prima di installarlo nel tuo ambiente agente.
  2. Controlla strumenti, credenziali e ambienti richiesti nel documento originale.
  3. Descrivi input e risultato desiderato; confronta l’output con le fonti.
npx skills add https://github.com/learnprompt/andrej-karpathy-skills --skill karpathy-llm-simulator

Prima di iniziare

  • L’installazione non include abbonamenti, quote API o accesso ai file.
  • Stelle e installazioni indicano attività, non un test indipendente di qualità o sicurezza.
Documento Skill originale

Contenuto dal repository con titoli, esempi, codice, tabelle, link e immagini preservati.

Skill 3: LLM as Simulator(LLM模拟器思维)

Source: https://x.com/karpathy/status/2037921699824607591 | https://x.com/karpathy/status/2049907410303865030 "Drafted a blog post → LLM argue the opposite" — 31k likes

Core Principle

Don't ask what the LLM thinks. Ask it to simulate what a diverse group of experts would argue.

LLMs are trained to please. A direct question gets a sycophantic answer. A simulation request gets a distribution of real perspectives — including the uncomfortable ones.

Karpathy's method: write a draft → ask LLM to argue the strongest possible opposite position → synthesize a better view.

The 4 Simulator Modes

Mode 1: Expert Debate Panel

Best for: technical decisions, architecture choices, research directions

Simulate a structured debate between these 3 expert personas on [TOPIC/DECISION]:

Expert A: [most optimistic / pro position]
Expert B: [most skeptical / con position]  
Expert C: [pragmatic outsider / unexpected angle]

For each expert:
- State their core argument in 3 sentences
- Cite 2 specific examples or data points they'd use
- Identify what they'd say is the FATAL FLAW in the opposing view

After the debate, synthesize: what's the strongest hybrid position that survives all three critiques?

Topic: [YOUR_TOPIC]
My current position: [YOUR_DRAFT_VIEW]

Mode 2: Steel Man the Opposite

Best for: before publishing, before committing to a decision

I'm about to [ACTION / PUBLISH / DECIDE]:

[YOUR PLAN OR DRAFT]

Steel man the strongest possible argument AGAINST this. Be merciless.
Don't hedge. Don't say "while this has merit...". 
Argue as if you genuinely believe the opposite and need to convince a skeptical expert.

Then: what would it take to make my original position survive this attack?

Mode 3: Pre-Mortem Simulation

Best for: project planning, product launches, major decisions

Imagine it's [DATE 6 MONTHS FROM NOW] and [YOUR PROJECT/PLAN] has failed completely.

Simulate 3 different failure modes — each from a different root cause:
1. Technical failure: what went wrong in the implementation?
2. Strategic failure: what assumption proved wrong?
3. Execution failure: what human/process error occurred?

For each: describe the specific sequence of events that led to failure.

Then: what early warning signals would have been visible by [DATE 1 MONTH FROM NOW]?

Mode 4: Socratic Drill

Best for: testing your own understanding of a concept

I believe I understand [CONCEPT]. 

Ask me 5 increasingly hard Socratic questions to test my understanding.
After each answer I give, probe a potential gap or inconsistency.
At the end, grade my understanding on a scale of 1-10 and identify my biggest blind spot.

Start with question 1.

Anti-Sycophancy Patterns

Always add one of these to prevent the LLM from capitulating to your framing:

  • "Do not soften your critique because you think I want to hear it."
  • "If my position is clearly wrong, say so directly."
  • "Ignore that I wrote the original draft — evaluate it as an anonymous submission."
  • "Your job is to find the fatal flaw, not to validate."

Decision Framework

Before any major decision:
1. Write down your current position (1-2 paragraphs)
2. Run Mode 2 (Steel Man the Opposite)
3. Update your position based on the strongest critique
4. Run Mode 1 (Expert Debate) to get broader perspective
5. Make the decision — now you've genuinely stress-tested it

Total time: 15-20 minutes. Quality of decision: dramatically better.

When NOT to Use This

  • For factual lookups (just ask directly)
  • For code generation (use agentic engineering instead)
  • When you've already decided and need to execute (move forward, don't ruminate)

Workflow

属于工作流:反偏见决策(任何重要判断)

位置上游下游
入口用户面临重要决策时直接触发karpathy-understanding-first(验证自己是否真正理解)

完整链路:llm-simulator → understanding-first → system-prompt-learning

也在月度体检工作流中用于 stress-test 月度结论。

Prompt Contract

text
Simulate a structured debate between 3-5 expert personas with conflicting incentives on <DECISION/TOPIC>. Each persona must: state their core argument, cite specific evidence, identify the fatal flaw in opposing views. After the debate, synthesize the strongest hybrid position that survives all critiques. End with: key assumptions I must verify myself.

Verification Checklist

  • [ ] 至少有 3 个角色,且利益/立场互相冲突
  • [ ] 每个角色都给出了具体论据(不是泛泛而谈)
  • [ ] 每个角色都指出了对方的致命缺陷
  • [ ] 综合结论经受住了所有角色的攻击
  • [ ] 列出了「我必须亲自验证」的假设清单
  • [ ] 没有出现讨好用户原始立场的倾向
dallo stesso repository

Altri Skills

Tutti gli Skills
learnprompt
Community

karpathy-agentic-engineering

Apply Karpathy-style agentic engineering to any coding or building task. Use this skill when the user wants to set up an agent-driven workflow, needs to write a CLAUDE.md or AGENTS.md, wants to orchestrate agents with clear success criteria, or says things like "agent loop", "let the agent handle it", "agentic coding", "set up agent workflow". Includes the 7-step inner loop from Karpathy claude coding notes.

Installazioni / 1h
1
GitHub Stars
130
Aggiornato
10 lug
learnprompt
Community

karpathy-education-first

Apply the education-first mindset — make everything you build teachable, create nano-project explanations, write for beginners. Use this skill when the user wants to explain a project to beginners, create a tutorial from code, write documentation that teaches (not just documents), make a concept accessible, or says "make this teachable", "explain like im a beginner", "nano project version", "teaching version", "explain from scratch", "blog post about this". Based on Karpathy 243-line GPT and Eur

Installazioni / 1h
1
GitHub Stars
130
Aggiornato
10 lug
learnprompt
Community

karpathy-idea-files

Create and share ideas as abstract Gist-style specs instead of code — letting agents or others implement. Use this skill when the user wants to capture a new idea quickly, needs to write a project spec for an agent to implement, wants to share a concept without building it first, or says "write up this idea", "create a spec", "gist this", "idea file", "agent can implement this", "brief for this project". Based on Karpathy 27k-like LLM Wiki Gist post and GitHub repo.

Installazioni / 1h
1
GitHub Stars
130
Aggiornato
10 lug
learnprompt
Community

karpathy-methodology

Apply Andrej Karpathy AI methodology and principles from his 2023-2026 insights. Use this skill when the user wants to apply Karpathy-style thinking, needs guidance on agentic engineering, LLM knowledge bases, minimalist coding, understanding-first principles, or any of the 14 core methodologies distilled from his work. Also triggers on: "karpathy method", "karpathy approach", "karpathy way", "AK style", "like karpathy does", "karpathy principles", or when user asks how Karpathy would approach a

Installazioni / 1h
1
GitHub Stars
130
Aggiornato
10 lug