select-next-pair

select-next-pair

Purpose

Select the next comparison pair to maximize expected information gain while respecting unresolved uncertainty and coverage.

Input contract

required: [candidate_set, current_ratings, uncertainty_matrix, comparison_budget]
optional: [pair_history, exploration_policy, exclusion_constraints]
constraints: [candidate IDs are stable; expected information gain uses the declared model and available evidence]

Procedure

1. Enumerate eligible unjudged pairs and compute their current uncertainty and decision relevance.
2. Estimate expected information gain under the declared comparison model, including the value of resolving a tie or cycle.
3. Exclude pairs blocked by scope or data constraints, then select the highest-value eligible pair.
4. Return the selected pair, rationale, alternatives considered, and the budget impact.

Output contract

produces: [selected_pair, information_gain_estimate, candidate_pair_table, selection_rationale]
delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, uncertainties, decisions, recommended_jumps]

Quality gates

• The selected pair is eligible, not already resolved under the same model, and has a stated information-gain rationale.
• If all pairs are exhausted or blocked, return an explicit stop reason.

Failure and counterexamples

Do not select a pair solely because it is adjacent in a list. Expected information gain cannot be claimed when uncertainty inputs are absent.

Provenance map

• resolved: pair-selector